Tuesday, November 17, 2026

What Startups Need to Know About Dealing with Lawyers

Fundraising, personnel and labor issues, strict adherence to laws and regulations, positioning with shareholders.... Startups in the seed stage are often faced with a variety of problems as they expand their business. In these days of strong compliance awareness, it is even more important for even a newly established company to pay attention to legal and labor issues. The key to success in such a situation is "how to deal" with lawyers. However, although startups are in fact in need of lawyers, they do not have many opportunities to come into contact with them. To address this issue, we invited three lawyers to participate in creww academy vol. 07 "Lawyer Night" under the theme of "Questions about lawyers and legal affairs. The three attorneys spoke about issues that startups may face based on their knowledge and experience as attorneys.

*This article is reprinted from an article published in CREW MAGAZINE on September 19, 2018.

Topics
1. opening a business by yourself or with a colleague
2. want to start a new business now that the foundation has been established
3. how to deal with lawyers
4. contract
5. lack of manpower
6. becoming a well-known company
7. aim for exit
 
Speakers
(1) Hiroyuki Hasegawa
Partner, Kataoka Sogo Law Office
(2) Shinao Takamatsu
Partner, Kataoka Sogo Law Office
Yuichi Nojiri
Nojiri Law Office, Attorney at Law
 

1. opening a business by yourself or with a colleague

- Points to keep in mind when starting a business alone
Attorney Nojiri:(When starting a business as a corporation (such as a joint stock company), the most important thing to understand is what is the status of a shareholder.
This is because the general meeting of shareholders, as the highest decision-making body of the company, will decide the course of the company itself. In other words, in the case of one person, the decision is made by the shareholder = me, but in the case of several people, a majority vote is always required. It is common for companies to become stuck (stagnant) in a situation where they may have the same thoughts as a business, but not necessarily the same thoughts as an operation.
If two people start a business and each own 50% of the shares, it is possible that nothing will be decided.
If more than one person is to be a shareholder in the company and proceed with the management of the company, we recommend that a leader be determined who owns a majority of the shares and has the final say (i.e., becomes the leader himself/herself).

-[Point
→When starting a business with more than one person, be sure to assign a leader to make the final decision.
→As the number of shareholders increases, the hurdle to holding a shareholders' meeting itself rises if even one shareholder has a different view of the business.

Attorney Hasegawa:As for the Corporate Law, a system has been established whereby those who own 90% or more of the company's shares can demand the sale of shares to minority shareholders who own less than 10% of the company's shares. By taking advantage of this system with fair compensation, minority shareholders can be eliminated to some extent.
However, we have to understand that the presence of an outside shareholder, even if it is only one share, at once raises issues related to shareholder meetings and makes decision-making more time-consuming.

2. want to start a new business now that the foundation has been established

-Things to keep in mind when raising funds
Attorney Hasegawa:When receiving investment from private investors or venture capitalists, be careful when passing on a majority stake. Under corporate law, if you give away a majority of your shares, you will not be able to secure a directorship for yourself, the person who started the company, and you could be forced out of the management of the company.
In a stock corporation, it is a given that many things are decided by the general meeting of shareholders. If you give a majority of the votes, you have nothing to complain about, according to the logic of capital, even if you are fired.

In addition to the rights of shareholders under the Companies Act, the investment agreement that is concluded when accepting an investment or the shareholders agreement that is concluded with the company or the founder when multiple shareholders invest in the company usually stipulates that the shareholders can monitor the management of the company (for example, the shareholders can report on the business on a regular basis, have a director serve on the board of directors, participate in board meetings, etc. as an observer and express their opinions, and require the investors' consent for decisions on important matters). (e.g., periodic reports on the company's business, having one director participate as an observer and express his/her opinion, requiring investors' consent for decisions on important matters, etc.). From the company's standpoint, it would be preferable to have the investors invest only to a certain extent and not to sign a contract that contains unnecessary provisions, but this is not always possible.
From the standpoint of an investor, especially in the case of a shareholder who collects money from customers such as venture capitalists, it is certainly necessary to request such a thing as long as the investment is made, and the above provisions are not necessarily unreasonable. However, it is important to understand the contents of the agreement before signing it, as accepting it without any hesitation may cause serious restrictions on the management of the company. As a general rule, it is good to know that it is better for a company to be as simple as possible when it comes to the contract it signs at the time of investment.

Point]
→No extra contracts for investments in the form of minority shares.
→Many shareholders are willing to interfere to some extent as long as they invest in the company, but in some cases, the more details in the contract, the more disadvantageous it becomes for the startup side.
→In many cases, the investor prepares the contract. (It is necessary to examine the contract so as not to be at the mercy of the investor.) Æ

3. how to deal with lawyers

-Drawing the line between legal counsel and consultation-level counsel.
Attorney Nojiri:Since the legal advisors are in daily contact with the client company, they know the color of the company and the people who work there, so it is easy for the lawyers to consult frankly with them and give advice from various aspects. If you come to us from the start-up stage, we can give you advice based on our understanding of the growth process and the founder's thoughts and feelings, and we can sometimes reflect the founder's feelings in how we treat employees after the company has grown into a large corporation.
It is never the case that we do our work properly because we are not a client, but when you are a corporate lawyer, you can establish an ongoing relationship with us, which can make a difference in the advice you give us.

Point]
→Establishing a trusting relationship with an attorney early in the start-up process allows for close consultation.

Attorney Takamatsu:Personally, as I have developed a practice that specializes in financial and information law, I often consult with them on (legal) confirmation of business schemes.
In the initial consultation when attacking a gray area, it is important to be offensive and defensive. By "defense," we mean first confirming whether or not there are any fatal legal issues in the entire scheme. We sometimes see situations where we consider whether or not the service needs to be terminated after the start, even though the system was built ahead of time, so we would definitely like you to confirm this at an early stage. As an offensive measure, consult closely with an attorney. In fact, lawyers often handle similar work across the board, so they have accumulated legal knowledge in a general sense. Therefore, I believe that we can provide you with detailed information on legal matters, including the line between gray and not, so I think it is a good idea to utilize consultation with an attorney as an offensive measure.

Point]
→ Use offense and defense for initial consultation with an attorney.
→Even if you are not an advisor, you can use it as a quasi-consulting service for a consultation fee.
(Legal counsel fee quotes)
→Most advisory contracts are expected to be 50,000 yen per month, with a frequency of several consultations that last for a short period of time.
→ Some companies contract for 150,000 a month for a year.
→The cost and content of advisory contracts vary depending on the type of business, content of consultation, and frequency of consultation.
→It is also recommended to consult with the company at once in the early stages of starting a business.
(Consultation fee rates for shots)
→(1) A consultation is often in the range of 100,000-200,000 yen, based on the assumption that several meetings and e-mail correspondence will be required.
→ If you want to consult closely, you can do so through referrals

4. contract

-The drafting of contracts is an unavoidable part of conducting business. Is it safe to utilize template contracts available on the Internet?
Attorney Nojiri:Recently I have been particularly interested in checking out contracts between various companies. It is not possible to pick up a good draft contract that fits each company's business online. You need to make sure that the contract is well drafted to fit each company's business. Incidentally, the quality of a company can often be determined by whether or not it has a well-drafted contract. If we get the impression that a company is not capable of basic considerations, the legal department will instruct the client to be careful about doing business with that company. We can also tell from the contract that the company has a bad character (laughs).
In fact, major brokerage firms and venture capital firms often check the contract carefully, so it is better to make sure that the contract for core services is well drafted.

Point]
→Æ Do not easily use a template contract published on the Internet just because it is close in form.
→There is a lot of unreliable information on the Internet.

Attorney Hasegawa:As a precaution when asking an attorney to review a contract, I think it is best not to complete the request by email alone, especially if the connection was made through a referral. From the lawyer's point of view, if he/she receives an e-mail from someone he/she has not yet met, he/she does not know the background of the contract and the power relationship with the contracting party, so he/she will (for goodness sake) give feedback to the client in a way that is favorable to the client. Then, even though the client is in a lower position than the other party to the contract, the contract becomes more aggressive, and the client says, "I can't accept this kind of stipulation. This can lead to frustration on both sides, and above all, the client may send the contract to the other party without checking it carefully, which could destroy the business negotiation.

Point]
→Æ The attorney should be given the background of the transaction, whether by phone or in person.
→ In some cases, the contract may be broken.
5. lack of manpower

-When increasing human resources as the business grows, the company organization should be aware of the following points
Attorney Nojiri: Labor-related laws and regulations are designed to protect workers. If labor laws are not followed correctly, it is honestly difficult for a company to win in the event of a labor dispute. A typical example of a labor-related dispute is a claim for overtime pay. The company may argue that "he was not working at that time," but since waiting inside the company for specific work instructions also constitutes labor, it is impossible for the company to decide not to pay overtime if it does not send the worker home and allows him to remain in the company.
I think the point of personnel and labor affairs is also the fundamental "importance of human relations".

Point]
→ Believe that labor laws are there to protect workers.
→The key to human resource management is to value relationships.

6. becoming a well-known company

-With the development of the Internet, we must be careful about leaking personal information, bashing, advertising expressions, etc.
Attorney Nojiri:Slander on the Internet is common, but when it comes to companies being slandered about their products, it is extremely difficult to get them removed. It is very difficult to win in court unless the criticism is on the level of a list of terrible lies, such as "If you use that product, you will die. In addition to the difficulty and cost of finding the culprit in the first place, even if the culprit is found, it is not always possible to have the comment removed from the Internet. As a company, we have to endure criticism, and we should be careful every day not to be unfairly criticized.

Attorney Takamatsu:When developing membership-based services that handle personal data, the value of personal data increases as the amount of membership data increases.
The business would then want to "share the information with a partner" or "sell the data," but in principle, the consent of the member himself/herself is required when transferring the data. Therefore, if sales of data or other developments are anticipated, it would be beneficial to consider including clauses on the provision of personal information to third parties in advance in consent forms, rules, contracts, etc. regarding the handling of personal information, in light of such developments.

Point]
→Æ It is necessary to endure criticism of your company's services and products on the Internet.
→When operating a service that handles member information, it is recommended that the terms and conditions be drafted with a certain degree of forward-looking business development in mind.

7. aim for exit

-In the process of a startup seeking to exit, there will be an increase in the number of consultations with attorneys. What should be consulted in such cases and what should be anticipated regarding the matters to be consulted are
Attorney Hasegawa:One of the first things to do is to make sure that basic controls over the stock are in place. Who are the shareholders, has a list of shareholders been prepared, and are share certificates well managed? There are many unlisted companies that do not have these basic things in place, but M&A firms want to avoid companies that do not have even basic stock management in place. In addition, as for labor issues, it is necessary to make sure that the company has a system in place to ensure that overtime rules and regulations are in place and that the company is not in an excessive working environment.
And as for the biggest problem, be careful not to allow anti-social forces (anti-corporation) to become shareholders. There have been cases where companies have been unable to list their shares due to transactions with them, so be sure to include a clause in your contracts that excludes anti-social forces.

Point]
→Make sure to include an anti-company exclusion clause in the minimum part of the contract.
→Companies that do business with anti-competitive companies will lose social credibility.
→Even for companies with a market capitalization of several hundred billion, there are cases where they cannot go public or do M&A because of the involvement of an anti-company.

This year's "Lawyer Night" focused on how to deal with lawyers and startups, an area that is often difficult to anticipate when starting a business. Since this is a point that we are not usually aware of, the lawyers gave a lot of detailed advice, and there was a lot of lively discussion at the meetup, making it a meaningful event for seed to early stage startups.

PORT Editorial Officehttps://port.creww.me/
PORT by Creww is an open innovation media for startups, entrepreneurs, entrepreneurs in recovery, and companies seeking to create new businesses on the theme of social issues, operated by Creww Co.

Featured

東芝のオープンイノベーション、協業検討に進む2社が決定 ダイナミックマッププラットフォームとArithmerを選定

ReGACY Innovation Group株式会社(東京都千代田区)は、企画・運営パートナーとして支援する株式会社東芝の「Toshiba OPEN INNOVATION PROGRAM 2026」で、協業検討に進む参加企業2社が決定したと発表した。7月に募集した共創プランの中から、ダイナミックマッププラットフォーム株式会社とArithmer株式会社を選定。両社は東芝グループの「Hybrid-3D LiDAR」と「気象データサービス」を活用し、物流・インフラ分野などでの新たなソリューション共創を目指す。12月中旬の成果発表会に向け、実証と事業性検証を進める。 本プログラムでは、2026年7月6日から7月26日まで参加企業を募集しており、応募のあった共創プランの中から、ダイナミックマッププラットフォーム株式会社、Arithmer株式会社の2社が選定されました。 両社は、東芝グループが保有する「Hybrid-3D LiDAR」および「気象データサービス」の技術・データを用いて、物流・インフラ分野やデータ活用領域における新たなビジネスソリューションの共創を目指します。 今後は、12月中旬に予定されている成果発表会に向けて実証や事業性検証を進めるとともに、事業化を見据えた協業の検討を加速していきます。

新潟日報社、オープンイノベーションプログラム2026ピッチ審査会で「三ツ目」「想ひ人」2社を選定

新潟日報社は8月4日、「新潟日報社 オープンイノベーションプログラム2026 ピッチ審査会」を開催した。Creww株式会社が提供する「Creww Growth」を活用し、5月15日から6月15日にかけて新潟県や社会が抱える課題解決に向けた協業アイデアを募集。応募61件の中から書類審査を通過した8社がピッチに参加し、審査の結果「三ツ目」(新潟県三条市)と「想ひ人」(東京都)の2社を選定した。今後は実証事業等を通じて事業化を進める予定。

【ヤマサキ × BeeInventor】高温下での過酷な作業環境から、データは命を守れるか——創業151年の工業炉建設会社とスマートヘルメット新興企業が挑む「熱中症ゼロ」の現場

明治8年創業の株式会社ヤマサキは、建設業界向けアクセラレータープログラム「ヤマサキ×オープンイノベーションプログラム2024」を通じて、スマートヘルメットを手がけるビーインベンターとのPoCを実施した。内部温度800度を超える製鉄炉の傍らで働く現場作業員の熱中症リスクをAIで早期検知するという挑戦は、今まさに第2フェーズへと移行しようとしている。プロジェクトリーダーの向井裕一氏と、BeeInventor(ビーインベンター)のNao SeoChon氏に話を伺った。

【ヤマサキ × CHAOSRU】「誰も知らない技術」を、誰もが体験できる価値へ——創業151年の工業炉建設会社とVRスタートアップが挑む、採用×認知の壁の壊し方

明治8年創業の株式会社ヤマサキは、製鉄に欠かせない築炉の技術を持ちながら、業界・企業の認知度の壁が採用の課題となっていた。この課題の突破口を探るべく参加したのが、『ヤマサキ×オープンイノベーションプログラム2024』だ。プログラムを通じて、VR・XR技術を核とする株式会社CHAOSRUとの協業をスタート。2025年7月から始まったPoC(実証実験)では、高校生向け採用説明会へのVR体験の導入により、ブース来訪者数に明らかな変化が生まれている。アクセラレータープログラムを通じたスタートアップとの協業で何が動き、何が見えてきたのか。株式会社ヤマサキのプロジェクトリーダー 田中敏彦氏と、CHAOSRU代表取締役の内藤薫氏に話を伺った。