This article provides a digest of the "creww academy vol.02 - Learning from Startup Science, the Law of Pivot" held at "docks" on Wednesday, May 23.
*This article is reprinted from an article published in CREW MAGAZINE on August 1, 2018.
The speakers this time were Mr. Masayuki Tadokoro, who has written a book entitled "Startup Science" on how to increase the probability of success in starting a business, and Mr. Yutaka Ishikawa of Knightley Corporation, who himself has a track record of successfully pivoting as an entrepreneur.
The ratio of men to women in the audience was about 80% male and 20% female. I was a bit nervous about the number of men in the audience, wondering if it was because the theme was difficult to understand (see ......), but it was not the case.
From here, we will begin with the premise, "What is a pivot?" and we will provide a summary of the event's content from the premise.
1. What is a pivot in the first place?
Pivot is "changing strategy without changing vision.
A vision is a clear statement of "whose problems we will solve and in what way. If you are going to change this fundamental point, it would be wise to start the company over in the first place. Pivot" is to change the strategy (i.e., how to deliver and present the product to the customer, and the scope of the product itself) without changing the story of the company itself, which is the foundation of the company.
Two-thirds of what are now called unicorn companies, such as Instagram and Google, have experienced pivots, he said.
It would be best if the direction and strategy were fixed from the beginning and no pivoting, but that is not the reality. The key is to learn something from the customer and pivot to find the right business model.
Often, he says, people easily pivot, thinking, "Many unicorn companies have experienced pivots, so maybe we should pivot, too."
According to Mr. Tadokoro, "What is important in pivoting is to measure data. If the UX is basically continuously improved, but the functionality is still lacking, for example, then we can develop it based on user stories. If you have done all of this and it was not possible, then the appropriate course of action is to pivot because the business model was not good enough.
If you keep the same business model and continue to improve it but cannot achieve PMF (product market fit), you may want to pivot," he said.
So, what specific conditions must be met to be considered an appropriate pivot?
2. What are good pivots, bad pivots, and types of pivots?
Mr. Tadokoro indicates three main conditions for a good pivot.
The business model must be done, it must be based on objective data, and it must be convincing to the members. If any of these are missing, it is not a proper pivot.
If you are convinced but have not done it, it is a pointless pivot that is a waste of time. On the other hand, a pivot that has been completed but is not convincing to the team members is a risky pivot that risks team collapse. In addition, a completely subjective approach without utilizing qualitative and quantitative data will lead to the worst kind of pivot, which will lead to a continuity crisis.
And pivots that are not based on customer insights, such as being driven by business partners or investors, are also not appropriate.
He then moved on to explain the types of pivots.
Mr. Tadokoro advocates six types of pivots.
The "customer segment pivot," a change of direction due to differences in needs from the expected customers, led by Groupon.
Zoom-in pivots" represent Instagram, which has created a focused product that focuses on services that allow users to share photos, which was originally one function within a service that shared location information.
The opposite of this is the "zoom out pivot," which is a conversion to a more comprehensive service.
There is also "customer needs pivot," which is a change in direction to solve new issues that emerge from customer needs, "platform pivot," which is a change from a platform format to an application format (or vice versa), and "channel pivot," which is a change in direction of the channel to reach the customer. Channel pivot" is to change the direction of the channel to reach the customer.
We also need to carefully assess which type of pivot in our own business fits into this category.
3. Mr. Ishikawa, Knightley Corporation, who created a remarkable service after two pivots.
Mr. Ishikawa founded Knightley Inc. because he "really likes maps and the Internet. Rather than imitating others, he focused on what no one else was doing.
One of the results of our challenge to the basic concept of "collecting and analyzing data, incorporating it into products, and offering them to customers" is a service called "inbound insight". This service collects data on "where and how many foreign visitors come to Japan and what they enjoy," "how long they stay in each area and how much they travel by nationality," and independently analyzes how many business opportunities exist in each area of Japan and provides them as a web service and report. The data is then analyzed and provided as a web service and report.
Ishikawa says the strength of the service is that "when it comes to trends of foreign visitors to Japan, you can get it all from Knightley Inc." and it has been very well received.
The company was established in 2008, raised funds, gathered members, and began full-scale operations in 2011, when the first pivot took place.
At first, we thought that rather than creating a service for users from scratch and collecting data, we could gain knowledge from services that are already used by tens to hundreds of millions of people, so we started analyzing public SNS data such as Twitter to accumulate big data related to location, and developed a new B2B2C service for stores and users based on the concept of "local x social x smartphone. We developed a new B2B2C service for stores and users based on the concept of "local x social x smartphone" with the aim of creating a service that goes beyond GuruNavi, EatLog, and Groupon.
At that time, however, although we were able to analyze popular facilities, people's movements, and emotions to some extent based on the results of a large amount of data analysis, we did not have a deep understanding of the people side of the store, who "cannot afford to introduce new applications or web services to their operations.
There are a lot of stores, but very few places that would consider installing the service. Then we realized that we had to change the way we were doing things. says Ishikawa.
He continued, "I did not want to change my vision. I wanted to make the world a better place," he continued, "and 'How can I collect and analyze location-related data and make it useful for everyone?
So we did not change the fundamentals, but changed the approach to the first pivot, such as going to location-related vendors for proposals instead of stores. Incidentally, we also went to the University of Tokyo and other academic conferences.
Around 2014, we started to build on our successes that we could add value if we approached each private and municipal sector differently." He said.
The second pivot was in 2015.
Several customers who had noticed that the influx of foreigners visiting Japan would increase in the future requested "Is it possible to analyze inbound foreigners? Based on strong customer needs, they developed location data analysis technology for Japanese (Japanese) and created location data analysis technology for foreigners visiting Japan, and released it as a new product under the service name "inbound insight.
This service hit the needs of a wide range of customers and grew to be used by several hundred companies within a few months of its release, and by 3,000 companies within a year.
In 2017, Knightley Inc. began to further develop customers, partners, strengthen its organizational structure, and take on the challenges of the mobility domain, and has also achieved business alliances with major players in the automotive industry.
4. What are Mr. Tadokoro and Mr. Ishikawa's "laws for successful pivots"?
Following Mr. Ishikawa's lecture based on his own experiences, a dialogue between Mr. Tadokoro and Mr. Ishikawa followed.
The dialogue between the two men proceeded primarily as Mr. Tadokoro delved deeper into Mr. Ishikawa's pivot. Here,
Masayuki Tadokoro ("Tadokoro")I think there are a few things that have made Knightley Inc. successful.
First of all, there were no alternatives on the market, and I think the fact that Mr. Ishikawa himself went to the site and was obsessed was significant."
Yutaka Ishikawa ("Ishikawa")I don't think startups have much of a choice since they have such a small group to begin with, but I think I'd stick to going out into the field and doing things on my own."
private farm estatesIf I didn't like the map, I wouldn't have done every bit of it." Even though money is not involved, it is necessary to make a living. Didn't you feel discouraged while doing it from one end to the other?"
Ishikawa (city)I was almost discouraged. But the best thing about starting Knightley was that I kept my focus on creating innovative services in the areas of maps, location, big data, and the Internet. There was one person who agreed with me, and I think it was a good thing that I was able to start in that way. That is why, no matter how hard it was for me, I never came to the conclusion that I should quit. Normally, I think everyone would have quit.
private farm estatesI think the example of Knightley's focus on inbound is the customer segment pivot, but when you made that decision, were there any objections from your members? Maybe you convinced them, but how did you convince them?"
Ishikawa (city)I was the one who owned most of the shares, not the co-founders. I also told my employees at the time that only people who shared my vision could join Knightley, and that they had to like maps to join Knightley.
Also, I was the one who went to the site, so I think there was a sense of, 'If Ishikawa says so, I have no choice, let's give it a try.'"
private farm estatesI myself support startups, and the first thing I do is to refine the mission and vision. If we don't improve the resolution of the mission and vision, we won't be able to see what we need to do. Even if your skills are not very good at the moment, if you have a deep understanding of them, I think you have potential. It is important to "make sense of it.
Summary|Mr. Tadokoro: "Pivoting is a double-edged sword. But it is the greatest weapon for a startup."
Pivoting based solely on momentum can ruin a startup, but pivots can also be the greatest weapon," Tadokoro said. Pivoting is a double-edged sword, and it depends on how you use it, whether it will be very useful for your company or hurt you. When practicing pivot, it is important to fulfill all of the "conditions for a good pivot," as Mr. Tadokoro said.
The Q&A session was filled with laughter from the audience, and was filled with humor and specific examples. During the networking session after the lecture, there seemed to be a lot of interaction among the audience.















