*This article is reprinted from an article published in CREW MAGAZINE on February 8, 2016.
Shindo-san, you belong to the corporate planning department. What are the characteristics of a department involved in new business within a large corporation versus a start-up?
Large companies usually have a long history of pursuing a system of stable operations. The organizational strength and efficiency of large companies can be said to be their strength, but this is based on the assumption that the content and rules of competition are relatively stable. It can also be said that a kind of planning supremacy or experience supremacy is automatically incorporated into the structure, and that the emphasis is placed on consensus. However, in the process of creating a new business, we inevitably deal with unknown and unexplored elements, and sometimes common sense and customs within the company without malicious intent become obstacles. There may be other-blame to be attached, such as someone getting in the way or a bad system, but before that, conflicts and skill mismatches are inevitable within the parties involved themselves. In the first place, it is rooted in the structure, so it cannot be easily changed, and if it is changed, there is a natural worry that the existing business will lose its strength.
Such a problem should not exist, at least not in a startup that aspires to be a game changer. The internal and external resistance to launching something new is much different between a large company and a startup. That is why we were exploring the option of open innovation with startups.

Did you or your department have any distrust or resistance to start-ups?
As an individual, I am not at all. I have been with this company all my life, but due to the fact that I was often transferred out, I perceive myself as an inside outsider, partially lacking in common sense and customs within the company. I think I became immune to this when I was transferred to a general trading company, where I was engaged in the task of considering investments in startups, and I think this had a big influence on the formation of my current stance.
Since I started working on new business in the Corporate Planning Department, I have been thinking that the company needed a place to meet with a sense of discomfort that would bring awareness to the company. I wondered how to create a place where inside outsiders and outside insiders could meet, a place where the current status quo, such as Dejima, special economic zones, and the "one country, two systems" approach, could be retained, while still allowing direct contact with new winds and clues for new growth to emerge.
Large companies must have a vast amount of resources, both tangible and intangible, but a serious inventory only yields results that give a sense of deja vu. I felt that there must be some unacknowledged assets, and that it could not be that way. I was convinced that the startups' help would be faster and more accurate than the inside insider's textbook analysis of strengths. I was convinced that it would be quicker and more accurate for us to enlist the help of startups than for inside insiders to conduct a textbook strength analysis.

Accelerator program to meet quality startups and ensure open innovation
-Why did you dare to implement the accelerator program instead of directly looking for startups?
I took many things into consideration, but in the end it came down to intuition. First of all, based on my experience when I was transferred to a trading company, I was aware that it is no good moving around randomly or doing things systematically to come across quality startups, and that a moderately analog connection is the key. I was also afraid that I might make a mistake and create a strange taboo within the company. It would be a big loss if we were to say, "Accelerator programs and startups are no good," or "It's too hard to get outside winds in. So we were looking for the right hub. Then I happened to meet Ijichi-san, the head of Creww, at some workshop at the end of 2014, and I immediately thought, "Oh, this is the guy. I don't mean to push him into a stereotype, but he had the ideal appearance of being unwavering in his convictions, not pandering, and having a good cause.
The appearance...it's already intuitive there, isn't it? Please tell us about the process of meeting Ijichi and organizing the accelerator program, as well as the selection criteria.
We visited each other's offices several times since the beginning of 2015 and had serious, but rambling conversations with each other. We then engaged our director and signed a contract in June 2015 and oriented in September 2015. We received 61 applications through creww Collaboration (now creww Accelerator), which were checked by a staff of four and narrowed down to eight. The key points in selecting the projects were whether we could further develop our existing business from a new perspective, and whether we could envision a new business based on our own conscious and unconscious resources. Since our existing businesses are mainly composed of "golden trees," or businesses that are solid but no longer expected to grow by leaps and bounds, we needed to create new star businesses or businesses that would water and thicken the golden trees in order to build a business portfolio with the intention of sustainable growth.

How was this Accelerator Program? Were any stars born?
Although there were many difficulties in terms of the process, I am glad that some of the proposals actually made it to the entrance of concrete collaboration. In terms of the attributes of the proposals, I got the impression that there were more projects that watered the money tree.
Why is that?
Communication starts with us not knowing the other party, and the other party knowing our general impression of them. Therefore, unless we pay special attention, it seems that proposals naturally tend to cluster around our existing business.
As a result of our conscious effort to narrow down the themes and application requirements, we received many proposals that were not in line with the original purpose of creating a joint project, such as those that were essentially asking for sponsorship. I understand that this was the result of our own concern, "What if we don't receive any applications?

What I want from a startup is to be able to work with them without flattering them as others.
I understand that there were some difficulties as we started by exploring each other's ideas. Is there anything you would like to tell companies that are considering collaborating with large companies?
It is obvious that the startups that want to work together with us do not want to solve the management problems of large companies, and that large companies do not have the primary goal of growing and contributing to the startups. Therefore, I would like startups to do their best to realize their own ideals and solve their own problems, without pandering to large corporations. If they cannot "get along and work with others as they are," they will probably fail sooner or later, and if that happens, they will not be able to recover the time they have lost.
In addition, is there anything that you would like to see CREWW do more of?
I know that cleww's raison d'etre is to eliminate the structural mismatch of opportunity and capability that surrounds companies. First of all, we would appreciate it if you could be more involved as an outside insider in the process of uncovering the unacknowledged or undervalued resources that large companies have. It is almost a repetition of the definition, but if this work is left solely to large companies, it will only result in resources that have been trimmed of waste for existing businesses, and it will be difficult to elicit high motivation and accurate proposals for startups to work with large companies.
I also think that follow-up after a successful match is a very important function. Since they happen to be people of different customs, cultures, and beliefs who have encountered each other on Dejima, they are bound to have differences over trivial matters. It is normal for them to have very different ideas about investment and very different definitions of success from each other. The function of bridging the holes that large companies and startups tend to fall into is beneficial in enhancing the value of collaboration and the startup community. CREWW should have a priority touch here, and I think it would be good to have a new kind of service that allocates people, goods, money, and information to this area.








