This paper is a site operated by KDDIMUGENLABO Magazineindicates such things as location of person or thing, location of short-term action, etc.Published ArticlesReprinted from
Time to talk about the open innovation, collaboration and co-creation environment of companies in the last decade,Existence of "dedicated players" as a distinctive positionare listed below. It is not intended to support the efforts of individual companies, such as strategic consulting firms or venture capital firms that support the sale of their portfolio companies, but rather to serve as a broader platform.
There are two main categories: databases with a sourcing function to find collaborators and investors, and hands-on ones that focus more on the business itself. The former included CrunchBase and AngelList, while the latter was an acceleration method launched by TechStars, Y Combinator, and others. The latter, in particular, was also a fund, but in subsequent rounds, a corporate-sponsored program was created with a stronger image of corporate ties, and as you know, many of these programs have been undertaken in Japan as well. On the other hand, the companies that took the lead needed a high level of knowledge and understanding of startup investment and, above all, an internal structure, and it took several years for the companies to fully launch their efforts.
Like this,Ten years have passed since the start of new forms of open innovation initiatives in Japan.I will do so. How have the companies' approaches and situations changed? In this paper, we willFour companies that were among the first in Japan to continue their own initiatives as specialized players in this open innovation fieldto discuss the current state of co-creation in Japan. (All questions in bold are from the MUGENLABO Magazine editorial staff, and answers are from the following people.)
Norifumi Suzuki Representative Director and CEO, 01Booster (Zero One Booster)
Ten Ijichi Representative Director and CEO, Creww
Ryohei Ishii KDDI ∞ Labo (KDDI)

How Open Innovation Has Changed in 10 Years

First, I would like to ask you about changes in the market environment over the past five to ten years.
Ishii:Yes, KDDI ∞ Labo is exactly 10 years old this year, but at the time of its launch, it was at the time when feature phones were replacing smartphones. The so-calledIn the context of the collapse of the "racket business," the clear challenge is how to create a smartphone business.There was a The starting point was that telecom carriers also thought they needed to differentiate themselves with apps and would do well to collaborate with new startups. However, by the mid-2010s, it became clear that there were winners and losers in the app business,Startups are starting to move their main battlefield to real or IoT.I guess so.
KDDI may have been able to demonstrate its power in sending customers, etc. if it were only on the Web, but when business becomes "real," the playing field changes. Therefore, it is important toChallenge everyone to collaborate and co-create with startups with the help of large companies with real assets.The concept of the Partner Coalition was developed in an effort to promote co-creation activities, and it continues to this day. However, I have the impression that only a small number of companies are still voluntarily promoting such co-creation activities.
long vowel mark (usually only used in katakana)Creww has been in operation since 2012. Have there been any changes in trends?
Ijichi:Since the launch of the Open Innovation Program in 2012, a number of programs have been held in the Tokyo metropolitan area, but efforts outside the metropolitan area have been limited. The past few years,Numerous co-creations between local mid-sized companies and startups on Creww's platformI think it is now being done. In generalVery good match between seed stage startups and local mid-sized companies.I feel that this is a good thing.
For example, when a product has been verified to some extent and all that remains is to expand sales, it is easy to imagine a startup working with a major company. On the other hand, during the verification phase of a prototype, it is not necessary to have a large customer base. RatherCases in which speed to verification is a higher priority than scale.is often the case.
long vowel mark (usually only used in katakana)I see that the idea of collaboration and co-creation is spreading to local SMEs as well.
Nakamura:We areFutsugotivating open innovation practices in all types of companiesIn the beginning, some small and medium-sized companies in rural areas did not use the service even though it was free.Open innovation is a metropolitan area thing, right? I think it's just a metropolitan area thing, right?I think there were
But that has gradually changed, and in 19 years, under the previous administrationMunicipalities have been able to use their innovation budgets, and there is more momentum to attract and support companies to the region.I think that was one of the reasons for this. At first it was a sense of challenge to meet or not meet startups, but nowPhase of collaboration, such as how to implement in society and how to commercialize.The company has moved to
Ijichi:It's a medium-sized company in a rural area.In many cases, the owner-president is the owner of the company, and his light footwork allows for speedy progress in collaboration and verification.The startups should also have different partners depending on the phase they are in. Startups should also have different partners to work with depending on the phase,Local medium-sized companies x start-ups" is essentially a win-win model.It is.
There are many companies in the region that excel in technology, so I think we will see more and more examples of collaboration with technology in the future. Also, I think we will see more and more examples of collaboration with technology in the future,Cross-border initiatives like Japanese companies and overseas startupsI believe that the need for "new" products will also increase in the future, and I would like to see this kind of device implemented.
long vowel mark (usually only used in katakana)What are some specific examples?
Nakamura:Take, for example, the case of Asano Suisan, an inshore bonito fishery in Miyazaki Prefecture, and FACTORIUM, an AI startup in Otemachi,The idea is to turn the fishing captain's intuition into AI.The AI-ization of veterans."Aiming to create a new business model for the aging of the fisheries industry through co-creation.I think there is a case where the
Today, there are calls for the digitization of various sectors, especiallyLocal development, digitalization of primary industry and use of AI are still in the process of social implementationIt is. On the other hand, until now, it has been almost impossible to connect startups, which are numerous in urban centers, with local businesses,A situation where AUBA is being used more and more now that the platform is in place.It is.
Zero One Booster has been involved in many co-creation programs since it started in 2012. How do you feel that the way companies think about open innovation has changed?
Suzuki:The boom in open innovation has passed its peak, and the uncertainty of the results has been highlighted, which has increased the difficulty of reaching an internal consensus.In the Corona Disaster, the need for innovation is growing, but increasingly people are cautious about making additional investments because it is harder to make rational decisions about uncertain outcomesImpression.
However, statistics show that in the medium to long term, companies that are more active in innovation are more profitable, and here lies the dilemma of the short-term performance principle. Hence the platformer,Continuously presenting data and case studies to support decision-making, transcending time frames and company unitsmust be done. Innovation activities are usually driven by the thoughts of a "specific individual" rather than an organization. It is our role to support these "individuals," and our company, "The "Community of Innovation Professionals" is a very meaningful place to support those in chargeThe company is now in the process of
Failure Cases

I think that a new business is a series of failures, especially in a pattern that calls for discontinuous growth, which is often unfamiliar and inevitably lowers the probability of success. What kind of cases have you seen where mistakes have occurred in collaboration and co-creation with startups and other companies?
Nakamura:Cases that proceed before a contract is signed are dangerous.Yes. We have seen many cases of small and medium-sized companies that proceed without a legally binding NDA, especially when the NDA contains contents that have nothing to do with the NDA, and the IP is locked up after the NDA is signed.The JPO has guidelines on open innovation, so if you refer to those, you'll make fewer mistakes.I think.
Suzuki:Yes, open innovation is a mutual activity, and both large companies and startups have cultures. We should not blame either party for the antics of the other. It is also true that large companies tend to be slower to respond to change.Cases where companies accustomed to choosing subcontractors inevitably treat startups as subcontractors and equal partnerships are not possible.There were
Personnel changes at large companies also lead to difficulties for startups to assemble.Once the enthusiastic staff from the large company moves on, there will be a shakeout, and cooperation with startups will decline.I will do so. If only that were the case, but since the system is usually predecessor-negative, it is impossible to maintain continuity of measures. For that reason,Need to change the culture and climate of the entire company to an open innovation mindsetand I think we are being forced to work on it even if it takes a considerable amount of time.
Ijichi:After nearly a decade of working with many companies in this field, we have seen patterns of what works and what does not.Companies that are doing well are those that have an open innovation goal of "Creating an organization that can continuously generate innovationIf the company believes that the goal is "to create a new business," and that the new business creation methods (business matching, CVC, accelerators) in the process are only a stop along the way until the goal is reached.are many. Of course, each company does its best to create its own new business, but through this series of efforts and experiences, you are measuring the progress of your company's innovation stage each year as a KPI, both qualitatively and quantitatively.
It is indeed difficult to determine the time frame and perspective for a new business.
Ijichi:One pattern that does not work well is when a business matching or accelerator is conducted as a one-time event and the evaluation is based on how large a business is generated. In this case, unless a business that generates large sales is suddenly born, it will be difficult to continue the program the following year. Even if a large business is generated the first time, it will not be reproducible the next time,Medium- and long-term activities that build up know-how and evolve people and organizations create the essential value of open innovation.I think.
In fact, even companies in the construction and civil engineering fields that had no involvement with startups at all have collaborated with startups through the accelerator program and have invested in them, and are now looking for their next innovation creation initiatives. In the case of a financial company, it started with an LP investment in a venture capital firm, collaborated with a startup, made an investment, set up a specialized department, searched for overseas companies, and collaborated with and invested in an overseas company.
If a company makes a mistake in setting KPIs for how it evaluates open innovation, it will lose continuity, and if it does a good job of setting them, it will become an innovative organization year after year.We have witnessed this phenomenon many times.









